More School of the Americas

Wilkins94@aol.com
Thu, 18 May 1995 20:59:22 -0500

The amount of ignorance and animosity displayed towards the US military
by some members on this net is disheartening, to say the least. My point was
that most people who discuss the SOA on this net are already polarized over
the issue and are not open to any intellectual discussion regarding the
school, especially the cause and effect relationship between the curriculum
of the school and the track record of its graduates (both good and bad).
Most of those who summarily dismiss the relevance of SOA in the post cold
war era wouldn't know about the formulation of our hemispheric security
policy if it bit them on the rear. Everyone already knows the "truth"
Either its the "school of assasins" or "an absolutely integral part of our
hemispheric defense policy." The rhetoric against the school is so shrill
its become mere "background" noise to those in whose hands the school's
future belongs.

I still contend that an outside look at the school, even by agovernment
contractor, is a positive step. Those who argue that military men, even
retired ones, are incapable of original (even controversial!!) thought are
simply wrong. When you think of military men, the picture you should envision
should be the General Marshall or General Powell, not the characature of
napalm dropping, baby killing storm troopers that some would have you
believe. Our military is made of people like you -- racially, socially,
economically, ethnically, and yes -- politically. And if you think that
defense contractors and military officers simple kiss the ring of their
government master, read some of Rand Corporation studies on a wide array of
security issues, or some of the studies on US strategy in El Salvador written
by Army Lieutenant Colonels and Colonels while studying at the JFK center ar
Harvard during the mid-1980's. You would be surprised at the range of
opinions and options debated in free and open forums before reaching a
decision on policy matters. But some of you have it right about one aspect
of the miitary, when a policy decision has been reached and when our civilian
leaders have given us the order to carry it out -- we do. That is what
separates a constitutional military from a mob.

Maj Mark Wilkins
Ft. Leavenworth, KS
Wilkins94@aol.com